Aug 18, 2010

Is 'reverse racism' real?

Two high-profile incidents this summer thrust the concept of "reverse racism" -- minorities' belief in the superiority of their race over whites or discriminating against them -- into the spotlight. Former USDA official Shirley Sherrod lost her job and was publicly condemned last month after a heavily edited video surfaced of a speech she made implying that she was unwilling to help a white farmer. Sherrod was later vindicated, but not before she was forced to resign and the debacle cast doubt over her more than 40-year career in civil rights advocacy.

The U.S. Department of Justice also came under fire last month for its handling of a voter intimidation case against members of the New Black Panther Party for Self Defense. Critics, including an ex-Justice Department lawyer, claimed that the federal entity routinely failed to pursue cases involving civil rights violations against whites. Justice Department officials have said there wasn't enough evidence, and the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights is now investigating why the charges were dropped. spoke to leading academics and sociologists for their take on the term "reverse racism," and found that the concept is deeply rooted in the idea of race in the context of power and privilege in society, and has been internalized by Americans both black and white.

"When whites talk about reverse discrimination, I feel that they are making a silly argument, because what they really want to say is that we, people of color, have the power to do to them what they have done to us from the 13th century," said Eduardo Bonilla-Silva, professor of sociology at Duke University and author of Racism Without Racists, a book which examines how racism has evolved since the collapse of the Jim Crow era. Silva acknowledged that some minorities are prejudiced against whites, but said reverse racism implies minorities in the U.S. have the power and privilege to wholly discriminate against white people.

"The idea of reverse racism or reverse discrimination is non-sensical," Silva said. "If that by whites believe that we, people of color, have the power to enact and carry systematic policies against them -- because we don't have that."

"We do not control the economy," Silva added, "we do not control politics -- despite the election of Obama. We don't control much of this country."

The notion that racism is commingled with power was borne in part out of African-Americans defining the context of the national discussion on race following the collapse of the Jim Crow system and the end of the civil rights movement, according to Samuel Richards, senior sociology lecturer at the Pennsylvania State University. Political correctness and white guilt are also factors, Richards said. Richards, co-director of the "World in Conversation" at Penn State, which facilitates discussions on race between students across the university, said many Americans now believe if one race has power and privilege in society, they can be racist, but it's something else if you lack those things and still believe in the superiority of your race over another.

"Truthfully," Richards said, "they bought into that perspective." And although generally, it's conservative whites who use the term "reverse racism," "those same white people are accepting the debate--the assumption that only white people can be racist, or you wouldn't call it reverse," Richards said. "You'd call it racism."


1 comment:

  1. There are some interesting points in this article. The term "reverse racism" is not a valid term. Racism is racism. But a valid point in the article is that the whites who cry discrimination from blacks make it seem like now there will be institutionalized racism towards whites as it had been towards blacks. That idea is quite farfetched. There are for sure individual incidents of racism towards white individuals, but there really is no moral equivalency to what was years and years of legal racism, abuse, discrimination, and oppression. The biggest fear is taht the tables will be turned. And I simply cannot foresee that happening. Quite frankly I don't know any blacks that really want to do anything along those lines. Deal with the individual incidents, but we are no where near the point of whites being oppressed and truly marginalized.